What Happened to Canva
I started a YouTube channel on May 29, 2022. My son felt it would be a way to get us off the news channel. Well, now we have been on YouTube for four years. Not long after we started our channel YouTube started the Shorts section of the channel. Our first short was on Aug 30, 2022. We used shorts and quick little ads about what we had on our channel. At the time every guru of YouTube was saying use Canva. You can make quick and easy shorts on Canva. They talked about how easy Canva was to use and how all you had to do was pick the create your own YouTube shorts templet. Not only was Canva good for shorts but it was a wiz to use for avatars and banners too. You could make your short stand out with cute elements like floating and popping hearts, or sparkles. You could put backgrounds and the text was easy to use. Also you could make digital stickers and quick thumbnails for long view videos. So for shorts, Canva was our go to editor, especially when we started doing cat compilations.
As time went on Canva wasn’t working as easily as it was before. This is when the Magic started and Magic was AI.
Before the Magic (2021–2022)
When I first started doing Shorts in 2022, the Background Remover was a utility, not an "AI event."
The Location: It was easy to find. You clicked "Edit Image" and the button was right there at the top.
The Process: It was a "one-click and stay" tool. You clicked it, it removed the background, and then it locked that choice in.
The Stability: Back then, it didn't try to "re-think" your image. Once the background was gone, the element acted like a normal sticker. You could move it, resize it, or put a cat over a green screen, and it wouldn't "slide" or try to snap back to the original photo.
The 2023 "Magic" Turning Point
In October 2023, Canva moved everything into Magic Studio. This is when I started noticing the "noise":
The Change: They turned a simple tool into an "AI Process." Now, instead of just removing pixels, the software tries to "guess" what the foreground is every time you move the image. This is why things feel like they are "sliding"—the AI is constantly re-calculating the edges while you're trying to work.
The Video Background Remover: This was the big 2023 addition. It was amazing for Shorts because you could take a cat out of any video and put it anywhere. But because video is "heavy," it made the whole editor start to lag and glitch, especially on longer compilations.
I started paying for Canva in 2022 because I could remove just a cat in a video add a greenscreen background and in Clip Champ I could add a backgound of moving clouds and our cat would look like it was floating in the clouds.
To explain how it changed. I’m just trying to move this one little cat clip a hair to the left, and the whole program starts fighting me. It’s like the software thinks it’s the director and I’m just some intern.
I call it the 'Magnet Mess.' I try to nudge something, and—snap—it yanks the video right out of my hand and sticks it to the edge of the screen. I didn’t put it there! I want it where I want it, but this 'snapping' makes it feel like I’m trying to organize a bunch of refrigerator magnets that are all the same pole.
And then there’s the 'Sliding.' I’ve got my timeline set up, everything is peaceful, and then I hit play. Suddenly, the cat starts drifting across the screen like it’s on ice. I didn't add an animation. I didn't ask for a transition. But the AI decided it knew better and added this 'Match and Move' nonsense without asking. It’s making the viewers dizzy, and it’s making me lose my mind.
But the worst part? The 'Vanishing Act.' I spend an hour getting the green screen just right, removing the background so the cat looks perfect. I see it on the screen. I hit download. And when I open the file? The cat is gone. Or the background is back. Or the buttons to fix it have just... disappeared. They tucked the 'Lock' and the 'Remove' buttons inside some floating menu that plays hide-and-seek every time I move the mouse.
We’ve been doing this for four years, and it used to be simple. Now, it’s just noisy. It’s not 'Magic' if it makes my work disappear—it’s just a bad trick."
The thing that really upset me is that we started taking our blog seriously. So I was getting banners for the blog like for the Content Creator Store, and pictures of the backgrounds I will sell, and a button so people can press on it and find the store from any page on the blog. Also, I was making stickers to give away free to members. Well, Canva decided that transparent shouldn’t be transparent. It should have a pillow card. It is like everything is sitting on top of a fluffy pillow type card.
So this is the death knell of Canva for us. We are moving on to. Photopea, and staying on Clip Champ, and making having Shy Artist paint our own elements and maybe soon animating them in Blender 2d Grease pencil.
Sometimes it is better to just leave something that works well alone. AI isn’t necessarily the be all and end all of goodness.
Technique names to the new tools in Canva.
The Magnet: Officially called "Snapping" or "Auto-Alignment."
The Sliding: Officially called "Match & Move" (the AI tries to animate everything automatically).
The Vanishing Buttons: Part of the "Glow Up" update (where the fixed toolbar was replaced by a "Contextual Menu" that floats and disappears).
The Vanishing Clips: A glitch in the "Magic Media" rendering engine where AI edits don't always "stick" to the final download.
Please follow us by adding your email to the follow it box on the top right hand side column.
Please make comments. It helps us know what types of blog post you are interested in.
Please donate or become a member because even a dollar helps us to continue.
And take a look at or Content Creator Store. We just started it so there is a lot more that we will be adding.
